Today is my dad’s birthday. He would have been 85.
There’s some irony in Dad passing away exactly one week before his birthday in 2018. I can hear him now: “Well, I almost made it to 82–close, but no cigar!”
While last Sunday was pretty tough emotionally, as I thought back on that day I held Dad’s hand as he slipped quietly away, today I feel joy and gratitude.
I’m so grateful for my dad–for his love, his strength, his ambition, his infectious humor.
I’m fortunate that I have the kind of job that enabled me to spend the final nine months of his life by his side. That I was there for the physical trials as well as time together to laugh and learn from one another.
I realize, this year especially, how lucky we were not to face end-of-life struggles during a pandemic. A moment that keeps us away from those we love and want more than anything to protect.
Dad had 81 great years. As we near a full year of living with COVID, I think about how Dad would have approached this unanticipated and abrupt change to just about everything from 2020 onward. I think he would have shaken his head in disbelief and then adapted. Worn a mask. Stayed home. Limited trips to the grocery store and kept a safe social distance when he had to venture out. Remained peeled to the television and criticized Trump’s idiocy for shutting out the scientists and boasting about his own (non-existent) expertise.
During his lifetime, Dad encountered plenty of challenges–the Depression, cold Illinois days and nights without electricity to keep warm, the 1980s Farm Crisis, lean years when he and Mom struggled to pay the bills, one crisis after another involving my brother. He surely would have lamented the changes that have affected us all, but he wouldn’t have missed a beat in making sacrifices to keep himself and others safe and healthy. I can hear him, again: “The world changes, and you’d better learn how to keep up if you don’t want to be left behind.” Or worse, Dad.
In this morning’s LA Times, Rose Carmen Goldberg penned an essay about adapting to a new world. Following her father’s passing in an assisted living facility amid COVID, she joined a virtual grief support group. While initially, she was skeptical, she learned to appreciate the uniqueness of the forum and the compassion of the community she encountered.
Grief powerful enough to cross a virtual divide
By Rose Carmen Goldberg
It started like any pandemic-era Zoom meeting. I awkwardly angled my screen toward my bedroom wall to hide the clothes littering my floor. I changed into one of my button-up Zoom shirts. I joined others on screen. A gray cat slinked across someone’s keyboard. One participant struggled to turn on her video.
Then, suddenly, it felt very different. The moderator asked everyone to say the name of their loved one who had died. “My mom, Dana.” “My dad, Hal.” “My friend, Laura.” “My husband, Robert.”
Four months before that Zoom meeting, my dad had died alone in his assisted living facility in Oakland. As he declined after a stroke, I chased him from a distance. I videoed my way into rooms I could not enter because of COVID restrictions and blew him kisses from behind a glass wall. There’d been no memorial, nothing. It was as if my dad had vanished into thin air.
The hospice program that had cared for my dad encouraged me to join a virtual grief group. I declined brusquely. My loss felt so private. The last thing I wanted was to share it with strangers. Besides, Zooming about grief seemed tacky, emojis and chat boxes so incongruous with the sanctity of death.
A few weeks later, my mom called. She’d received my dad’s ashes. They came in a dark box engraved with gold designs. I imagined a van full of these boxes shuttling across the country, delivering the dust of the dead like holiday packages. I pictured my mom, in her one-room apartment in Berkeley, with this box for as long as the pandemic dragged on. I was too sad to cry.
The next night, my cellphone alerted me it was running out of space. It was clogged with photos from friends in quarantine trying to text their way out of isolation. Scrolling through the photos, I came across the last one I took of my dad. He seemed real, too big for that small box. Instantly, I felt like I was holding a bomb about to detonate. I threw my phone across the room. The next time a hospice counselor called, I said I was ready to join the virtual grief group.
I was nervous before my first meeting. I imagined I’d find Brady Bunch squares of grievers, a pixelated quilt of strange sad faces. I wondered if it made sense to sign up for more darkness. What I found, though, were heartbroken but whole people. Like me. Struggling through the pandemic and longing for a new future, while learning how to build bridges with loved ones lost to the past.
Every week a participant made a presentation about the person they had lost. We held frayed black-and-white photos of youthful smiling faces up to our screens. We shared color photos of these faces, sunken and weak. We talked about the lives lived in between.
As I showed photos of my dad, I felt suffocated by grief. Too choked up to talk, I closed my eyes. When I opened them, I saw group members crying with me. One gave me an air hug through the screen. Sitting in my bedroom alone, my loss felt shared, and lighter.
Technological glitches brought us closer, too.
One participant kept losing connectivity while trying to tell us about her mom. She frantically logged in again and again. Once she regained video, she fought futilely for sound. Her silent face caved in with pained defeat. These moments only reinforced how much we needed one another, former strangers, now friends in grief.
We shared milestones. In November, election anxiety muddied our mourning. At Thanksgiving , we hid from empty dining room chairs by eating turkey in our kitchens. Some decided not to send Christmas cards , not wanting them to be death announcements.
Our last meeting was the Monday before New Year’s Eve. With a new year and a COVID vaccine upon us, we pondered how we would reenter the world without our loved ones. “We are in the eye of the storm, it seems like help is on the way, but what will it feel like when the world reopens and starts spinning faster?” the moderator asked us.
I felt dread. Eventually, my dad’s assisted living facility will reopen to visitors. I’ll be allowed to go to the common room where we used to eat cookies. But it won’t matter because my dad won’t be there. I’ll be able to host dinners in my apartment. But my dad’s chair will remain empty.
For me, my group members, and many others, I realized, the reopening of society post-quarantine will cause a second period of grief.
There was solace, though, knowing I won’t be going it alone. I’ll likely never see my group members again. But I’ll carry them, like a blanket wrapped warm around me, a comforting reminder of the strength of human connection. Powerful enough to cross the vast virtual divide.
The final session ended unlike any other Zoom meeting I’d ever attended. The moderator angled her camera toward a table covered in candles. She lit them one by one for each person we’d lost. As we logged off, she whispered, “These candles represent your courage to comfort others. They represent the light of love.”